DavidB wrote:You have 4 x majors in snooker, golf and tennis so if the same in darts it’d be:
Lakeside
Winmau World Masters
World Matchplay
Grand Prix
What do you consider to be a PDC Major
-
- International
- Posts: 11844
- Joined: Thu Jun 28, 2012 3:56 pm
Re: 2018 PDC World Matchplay- Blackpool- 21st-29th July 2018
i am so sorry for my actions these last ten years, i'm going through a tough time
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
I would say the ET events are second tier and the Euro Finals is a major.
- ssjsa
- International
- Posts: 24565
- Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2011 5:02 pm
- Location: uddingston, glasgow
- Contact:
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
As you know Chris, we pride ourselves in being a balanced forum, despite what some ex posters might articulate.oche balboa wrote:For Balance the BDOs
Major: Lakeside, Winmau
2nd tier: Finders, World Trophy
Why don't you post a poll on which tournaments the Forum members consider BDO Majors.
2023 World Championship Prediction Competition winner
2019 Q School Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Weeks 9-16 Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Prediction Competition Cash Prize winner
Re: RE: Re: 2018 PDC World Matchplay- Blackpool- 21st-29th July 2018
To have the grand prix and UK open as majors yet the PL as a 'minor' I think is bonkers.phil davies wrote:Worlds
Matchplay
GSOD
Grand Prix
UK Open
That’s the big 5 in that order IMO. All other TV ranking events come under them as minor majors and then you have non ranking majors below them. Triple crown is utter nonsense IMO. It should be the big 5 as listed above so only Taylor and MvG done it thus far. Gando needs the Grand Prix which is an event I don’t ever see him winning TBH.
For a player there is no doubt the Worlds the Match play and the PL are the three they want to win. Absolutely no doubt. That makes them the 'triple crown' or whatever you want to call it.
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Lakeside.ssjsa wrote:As you know Chris, we pride ourselves in being a balanced forum, despite what some ex posters might articulate.oche balboa wrote:For Balance the BDOs
Major: Lakeside, Winmau
2nd tier: Finders, World Trophy
Why don't you post a poll on which tournaments the Forum members consider BDO Majors.
That's it.
Re: RE: Re: 2018 PDC World Matchplay- Blackpool- 21st-29th July 2018
No if a tournament like that was set up that wouldn't be a major instantly, however that's not a good example.phil davies wrote:Only because they offer the most money if a billionaire set up a tournament tomorrow offering a million to the winner does that make it a major? Not in my option it doesn’t. The PL is just a money making scheme nothing wrong with it but it’s deffo not a major.Skewball wrote:To have the grand prix and UK open as majors yet the PL as a 'minor' I think is bonkers.phil davies wrote:Worlds
Matchplay
GSOD
Grand Prix
UK Open
That’s the big 5 in that order IMO. All other TV ranking events come under them as minor majors and then you have non ranking majors below them. Triple crown is utter nonsense IMO. It should be the big 5 as listed above so only Taylor and MvG done it thus far. Gando needs the Grand Prix which is an event I don’t ever see him winning TBH.
For a player there is no doubt the Worlds the Match play and the PL are the three they want to win. Absolutely no doubt. That makes them the 'triple crown' or whatever you want to call it.
The PL has a great history, older than the Slam and only 2 years younger than the UK Open, people consider both majors, so I don't understand the prestige argument. Compare the growth of the PL to other tournaments, it's huge. The money on offer is great but that's not the only thing. And I'd say the PL is harder to win than the WGP or UK Open. Even to get a PL invitation is a career achievement, getting to the top 4 and winning finals night is as tough as it gets.
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Lakeside and Turkish open.BlueSpark wrote:Lakeside.ssjsa wrote:As you know Chris, we pride ourselves in being a balanced forum, despite what some ex posters might articulate.oche balboa wrote:For Balance the BDOs
Major: Lakeside, Winmau
2nd tier: Finders, World Trophy
Why don't you post a poll on which tournaments the Forum members consider BDO Majors.
That's it.
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
To me the obvious big 3 in the PDC pecking order as far as most fans go would be:
1) World Championship, 2) World Matchplay & 3) World Grand Prix
I personally would have the GSOD just behind those 3 and then would consider the UK Open and PL as part of a Big 6.
However i do think as far as the money and exposure goes that comes with the PL, i suspect a lot of players and pundits would have that at No3 in the list, but i think most darts fans might disagree with that view
1) World Championship, 2) World Matchplay & 3) World Grand Prix
I personally would have the GSOD just behind those 3 and then would consider the UK Open and PL as part of a Big 6.
However i do think as far as the money and exposure goes that comes with the PL, i suspect a lot of players and pundits would have that at No3 in the list, but i think most darts fans might disagree with that view
Re: RE: Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Not just a lot.paolo2144 wrote:To me the obvious big 3 in the PDC pecking order as far as most fans go would be:
1) World Championship, 2) World Matchplay & 3) World Grand Prix
I personally would have the GSOD just behind those 3 and then would consider the UK Open and PL as part of a Big 6.
However i do think as far as the money and exposure goes that comes with the PL, i suspect a lot of players and pundits would have that at No3 in the list, but i think most darts fans might disagree with that view
Ask any player , Grand Prix vs PL. It's not even a context.
The top three , triple crown, whatever. Is quite obvious.
Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: 2018 PDC World Matchplay- Blackpool- 21st-29th July 2018
That's not a fair comparison.phil davies wrote:Only because they offer the most money if a billionaire set up a tournament tomorrow offering a million to the winner does that make it a major? Not in my option it doesn’t. The PL is just a money making scheme nothing wrong with it but it’s deffo not a major.Skewball wrote:To have the grand prix and UK open as majors yet the PL as a 'minor' I think is bonkers.phil davies wrote:Worlds
Matchplay
GSOD
Grand Prix
UK Open
That’s the big 5 in that order IMO. All other TV ranking events come under them as minor majors and then you have non ranking majors below them. Triple crown is utter nonsense IMO. It should be the big 5 as listed above so only Taylor and MvG done it thus far. Gando needs the Grand Prix which is an event I don’t ever see him winning TBH.
For a player there is no doubt the Worlds the Match play and the PL are the three they want to win. Absolutely no doubt. That makes them the 'triple crown' or whatever you want to call it.
The players would prefer the PL, that's good enough for me because the players wanting it more makes it a more meaningful competition.
Re: 2018 PDC World Matchplay- Blackpool- 21st-29th July 2018
I definitely rank the PL as one of the biggest PDC majors.
The players are eager to play in it, only the best amongst the PDC field compete and what I especially like is that "luck of the draw" is eliminated completely. You've got to play them all and be consistently good over a longer period to make it in the PL. Gives it a very unique feel as far as I'm concerned.
The players are eager to play in it, only the best amongst the PDC field compete and what I especially like is that "luck of the draw" is eliminated completely. You've got to play them all and be consistently good over a longer period to make it in the PL. Gives it a very unique feel as far as I'm concerned.
-
- Site Admin/Mod
- Posts: 8395
- Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:56 am
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Matchplay, WGP, UK Open.
- ssjsa
- International
- Posts: 24565
- Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2011 5:02 pm
- Location: uddingston, glasgow
- Contact:
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
So the World Championship is not a Major.Black Velvet wrote:Matchplay, WGP, UK Open.
Have you nothing better to do than troll our threads.
2023 World Championship Prediction Competition winner
2019 Q School Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Weeks 9-16 Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Prediction Competition Cash Prize winner
-
- Site Admin/Mod
- Posts: 8395
- Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:56 am
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Trolling because I have a different opinion to you, gotcha.
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
I think the UK Open should have an increase in prize money if it doesn't want to slide down the list of big PDC majors. I mean it's got the history and the unique feel about it, but nowadays every other PDC major has a better prize fund! The GSOD, European Championship and Player's Championship Finals all surpassed it. Money isn't everything ofcourse but with the extremely busy PDC calendar these days it might get harder to compete for player's attention which can't be good for a major.
- ssjsa
- International
- Posts: 24565
- Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2011 5:02 pm
- Location: uddingston, glasgow
- Contact:
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Nothing to do with having a different opinion to me. Most posters on the forum share that.Black Velvet wrote:Trolling because I have a different opinion to you, gotcha.
When you post that the Matchplay, World Grand Prix and UK Open are the only PDC Majors, and exclude the W/C frankly your credibility as being anything other than a troll goes right out of the window.
2023 World Championship Prediction Competition winner
2019 Q School Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Weeks 9-16 Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Prediction Competition Cash Prize winner
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Upon thinking about it i am happy to accept what ever Barry Hearn tells us is a major
-
- Site Admin/Mod
- Posts: 8395
- Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 1:56 am
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
And that’s not trolling, apparently^^^^
- ssjsa
- International
- Posts: 24565
- Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2011 5:02 pm
- Location: uddingston, glasgow
- Contact:
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
Well his take would be pretty interesting. What does he consider to be the Majors?el_ringo wrote:Upon thinking about it i am happy to accept what ever Barry Hearn tells us is a major
2023 World Championship Prediction Competition winner
2019 Q School Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Weeks 9-16 Prediction Competition winner
PL 2019 Prediction Competition Cash Prize winner
Re: What do you consider to be a PDC Major
PDC: Worlds, Matchplay, WGP, UK Open
BDO: Lakeside Worlds, Masters
PL and GSoD both have invites and whilst I like the Slam, I would never consider it a major. Back in the day the IDL and the original WDT had good claims to be majors as proper cross-division events.
BDO: Lakeside Worlds, Masters
PL and GSoD both have invites and whilst I like the Slam, I would never consider it a major. Back in the day the IDL and the original WDT had good claims to be majors as proper cross-division events.